Spending More With Credit Cards Than Cash: It Doesn’t Apply to Everyone
Author: Nick
Category: Money
Topics: budget, credit
It is widely known that people tend to spend more with credit cards than if they use cash. Supposedly this is because you can “feel” cash leaving you.
From a scientific perspective, the paper bills passing through your hands release tiny particles found in the ink used to print money. Those particles travel through your bloodstream, sending a signal through your nerves straight to your brain which responds by releasing chemicals that make you feel remorseful (see diagram, top). The plastic of credit cards does not cause the same biochemical reaction, so you don’t get that feeling of regret (see diagram, bottom).
Okay, I just made up all that crap. But it’s still generally true that most people spend anywhere from 10-30% more when using credit than when paying with cash.
But I’m not most people.
As I’ve discovered in the last week, I tend to spend more when using cash than when using credit cards. And I think I know why:
- Cash tends to come from “nowhere.” I rarely have cash in my possession. If I ever do, it’s not on purpose. Usually it’s a gift or it comes from selling something I don’t need. I view it as extra money, so I’m more inclined to spend it on frivolous things.
- Cash doesn’t make it to my books. Because of the way cash typically enters my possession, I almost never log it in my personal finance tracking application of choice. And I don’t log receipts for transactions I pay in cash either. Thus there’s no line item in my monthly spending report to make me feel guilty for spending $60 in cash on two hot dogs at a baseball game.
- I don’t like cash. Cash takes up precious room in my wallet, and it invariably spawns something I hate even more: loose change. The sound of coins clinking in my pocket–ugh, it sends shivers through me. Perhaps I spend cash quicker because my subconscious is working to get rid of it faster. Of course, I could just deposit it in the bank, but going to the bank is another thing I don’t like doing.
So do you fall into the typical behavioral pattern of spending more with credit cards, or do you part with cash easier like I do?
Loading ...
10 Responses »
1.
plonkee
August 17th, 2007 at 4:01 am
I also spend more with cash. I just seem to have a compulsive desire to let it leave my wallet.
2.
Jonathan
August 17th, 2007 at 4:36 am
I definitely spend cash faster. If I use a credit card I know it’s being recorded somewhere. Big Brother helps me budget!
3.
Lauren
August 17th, 2007 at 12:08 pm
I used to have that problem where cash flew out of my wallet but over time I grew to have a large aversion to change as you described. So now cash generally stays in my wallet until i go deposit it and I use my debit card for most purchases.
4.
kitty
August 17th, 2007 at 2:59 pm
I also spend more with cash. Once I take cash out of an ATM I consider the money “already spent” whereas whenever I take out a credit card I know that it’ll increase the bill I’ll get at the end of the month and will still have to take out of my account.
Nowhere this is true more than when during vacations abroad. Once the money are converted into foreign currency, they just melt.
I am wondering if “people spend more with credit cards” studies come from people who carry balances. Someone who spends “a lot” more with credit card (which would apply to anybody who spends more than he has) will have huge impact on the averages. I would bet money that if they took only the people who pay balances in full, the conclusion would be vastly different. The thought of having to write this one big check all at once is a pretty big deterrent.
5.
Lord
August 17th, 2007 at 5:11 pm
My decision is made at the counter, shelf, or when ordering. Method of payment is irrelevant. Cash is more convenient for small items. Credit for larger ones. The only difference is pay now or pay at the end of the month. I prefer pay once, so I avoid debit cards.
6.
Jeremy
August 22nd, 2007 at 9:08 am
I was a waiter for years and unlike most of my co-workers, I never spent the money I just made. Even if I went out after work, I’d always pay with my check card. Besides having a record of how much money I was spending, I also get frequent flyer miles. In fact, I don’t feel like I actually have money until it’s deposited in the bank. (i.e. if I have a thousand dollars in my pocket and ten in the bank, in my mind I only have ten dollars). I just moved to New York City and the thing that’s been really hard to adjust to is the number of “cash only” restaurants.
Leave a comment
Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>Trackbacks & Pingbacks
[...] Money: Some people actually spend more by using cash over credit cards. With bonus funky [...]
Pingback by Stock Market Misery And The Mortgage Mess: The Roundup » Money and Personal Finance Blog In Silicon Valley — August 19, 2007 @ 9:43 am
[...] more when they use plastic (aka debit or credit cards) than when they spend cash. Nick over at Punny Money says this doesn’t apply to him, although his reasons are very different from [...]
Pingback by DebtFREE-Revolution » Blog Archive » Cash vs Plastic: Which do YOU spend more with? — August 21, 2007 @ 12:28 pm
[...] Use cash. Though some may say it’s not for them, you may try using cash to do your purchases. This is because it is recognized that those who use [...]
Pingback by Simple Tips For Grocery Shopping That Will Pad Your Pocket, Guaranteed — December 11, 2007 @ 10:23 am
[...] Use cash. Though some may say it’s not for them, you may try using cash to do your purchases. This is because it is recognized that those who use [...]
Pingback by Simple Tips For Grocery Shopping That Will Pad Your Pocket, Guaranteed — December 11, 2007 @ 10:23 am